Mark White, managing director of SME housebuilder Bargate, explains what steps need to be taken to ensure that the Your First Home scheme is a success.
The news that the Chancellor will be confirming the details about a Labour version of Help to Buy in the Autumn Budget statement has been met with overwhelming support and positivity from housebuilders.
Since Help to Buy closed to new applications in October 2022, there has been a marked reduction in the number of new homes built annually, despite the government’s own target to see 1.5 million built during the current parliament. We’re falling short by at least 100,000 new homes per annum. While planning policy has become easier to navigate, pre-commencement conditions and the costs of building new homes have risen exponentially, creating significant viability challenges for housebuilders. Consented sites are being stalled or substantially renegotiated.
For would-be buyers, higher interest rates and the cost of living have made homeownership out of reach for so many looking to take the first step. Prospective first-time buyers can struggle to save the required funds for a mortgage deposit, even if their income is sufficient to service the monthly payments.
Now we’ve been made aware that Your First Home will be officially announced on 28th October, MHCLG needs to work speedily with the Home Builders Federation, mortgage lenders and housebuilders to make sure the detail of the scheme is workable and can be rolled out as soon as possible. While a new iteration of Help to Buy is what the industry has requested for over three years, we’re told Your New Home will require developers to make financial contributions. It’s crucial that this mechanism is both viable and workable – for the PLCs and SMEs alike.
To replicate the widespread success of Help to Buy, all major lenders will need to support Your First Home with an attractive mortgage product. We need to see lower interest rates offered to reflect the loan-to-value ratio and reduced risk profile – compared to a 95% LTV product. If we assume the principal of a 20% government loan, a 2.5% buyer deposit, and say a further 2.5% developer contribution, we’re looking at a loan-to-value of 75%.
Another factor for success will be a workable wage cap that captures – rather than excludes – the full target market. I am also very keen to see the benefits of owning a new home factored into affordability calculations, reflecting the much lower energy bills and household running costs of living in a highly energy-efficient new build. Regardless of what rung of the ladder you’re on, there should be a meaningful mortgage rate differential for homes that are built to the Future Homes Standard.
Meanwhile, the appeal of getting on the housing ladder via Your First Home will need to be great enough to counteract the inevitable lost sales and delayed decisions that will impact the already subdued and fragile market we’ve encountered during 2026. Hopefully it’ll stimulate the market enough to see developers seek some flexibility and positivity from local planning authorities if live or upcoming sites need to be redesigned to accommodate more starter homes.
First-time buyers only account for 30% of the market, however. To achieve a marked difference in sales rates, there will still need to be some genuine cost of living help announced by John Healey. Every rung of the ladder needs to feel richer – or at least more financially secure – to enable housebuilders to increase sales and production. The ultimate aim is for the equity investment in live developments to be freed up and reinvested in new land purchases.
From a Bargate perspective, I am driving the business to produce some “affordable” private home designs akin to premium two-up/two-downs. I am also challenging our Land and Planning team to review our planning applications to make sure we align the mix of sizes with Your First Home (not necessarily bedroom numbers, but more efficient footprints to keep the square footage proportional).
This new iteration of Help to Buy needs to sit within the sweet spot of Shared Ownership and aspirational three-bedroom house designs, with a price point that is mortgageable and affordable for first-time buyers.




