Garden communities set to deliver 400,000 new homes

December 9, 2019 / Isla MacFarlane
Garden communities set to deliver 400,000 new homes

Garden cities have always been greeted with a degree of cynicism. In the late nineteenth century, when planning pioneer Ebenezer Howard first voiced his utopian vision of an alternative to the urban slums of his day, the Fabian News responded, “His plans would have been in time if they had been submitted to the Romans when they conquered Britain.”

The dormitory suburbs which followed in the wake of the New Towns Act have done little to convince the public that garden cities can offer a better way of life. However, a new report might persuade a cynics about the role garden cities could play in housing delivery.

A flagship Government programme centred on Garden Communities is set to deliver over 400,000 new homes – equivalent to a city the size of Birmingham – new research has revealed.

Conservative-led Governments have announced 49 Garden Communities since 2014 with the principle of such developments being widely accepted across the political spectrum.

Planning and development consultants Lichfields’ new analysis, How does your garden grow? reveals that garden communities are set to provide a total of 403,000 homes, up to 180 new primary schools, 56 secondary schools, and 600 hectares of employment land.

This is probably closer to what Howard imagined when he founded the Garden City Association, which built the leafy havens of Letchworth Garden City and Welwyn Garden City where thousands escaped to from the urban poverty which plagued Victorian cities.

Howard believed that by marrying the virtues of the city, including good wages, opportunity and amusement, with the advantages of rural life, such as low rents, natural beauty and fresh air, everyone could enjoy a better standard of life. However, the isolated suburbs which followed were far from what he had imagined.

The government sees the ‘Garden Communities’ programme as essential in its ambitions to build 300,000 new homes annually – but Lichfields’ research says it may take five more years before the programme gathers the momentum to make a significant contribution to this.

And, only if decision makers support their delivery over the next few years, will Garden Communities make this hoped for contribution to housing need.

With just 3% of homes completed, so far, and only a third (34%) enshrined in adopted local plans or with outline permission, the report from Lichfields outlines – for the first time – the delivery progress and characteristics of these new villages, towns and cities.

Lichfields finds that for around two thirds of the homes in the programme, there remains some planning uncertainty over the principle or scale of contribution arising from their development – slightly more than a third (35%) are identified in emerging plans that are subject to independent examination, and 30% are being promoted, but currently have no formal planning status.

Lichfields Senior Director Matthew Spry said: “The scale of the programme is undoubtedly ambitious, and it has progressed further than some ill-fated predecessors – such as ‘new country towns’ and ‘Eco Towns’. Across the 49 projects, there is a genuine commitment among landowners, developers and local authorities to bring forward fantastic new places for people to live, work and play

“While the Garden Communities are unlikely to deliver the lion’s share of their housing allocations until the mid-2020s, they could be delivering 16,000 dwellings a year by the 2030s making a significant contribution to meeting housing need.”

Lichfields research warns that for many councils they are likely to rely heavily on a Garden Community to help them achieve Local Plan housing objectives increasing the pressure on them to deliver in practice. Providing certainty and support will be vital in order deliver the homes that are required.

But Mr Spry cautioned: “Local Plans in many areas are heavily reliant on Garden Communities to meet their housing requirements: on average, one third of Local Plan targets depend on Garden Communities, but in some cases this is as high as two thirds.

“This means progress in meeting need is subject to the uncertainty associated with Local Plans, and Planning Inspectors in some places casting doubt over the principle and/or feasibility of some projects.

“In these circumstances, any failure or slow-down in delivery will leave those areas vulnerable to planning by appeal.”

“Garden Communities often require infrastructure to be provided early in the development which can impact on viability and their call on Government funding in shown by the £1.35bn of Housing Infrastructure Fund devoted to areas with these projects.

“The National Planning Policy Framework places much more emphasis on the deliverability and viability of plans, and those promoting Garden Community projects need to ensure they can accompany a positive vision for a new community with robust evidence that it can carry the burden of delivery expectation placed upon it.”

Lichfields analysis shows that 22 of 49 garden communities are standalone settlements, eight are new settlements linked to nearby towns, and the remaining 19 are urban extensions, such as this in Basingstoke, Bicester, Taunton and Wellingborough.

The standalone projects accounted for approximately one third of homes in the programme (35%), the linked new settlements another third (32%), and the urban extensions the final third (33%).

Some Key Findings:

  • Approximately 82,000 homes in Garden Communities currently have at least outline planning permission, a further 18,000 homes have submitted outline applications, bringing the total to 100,000 homes in the pipeline;
  • Garden Communities have so far delivered approximately 14,000 completions up to April 2019, with the vast majority of these within Garden Towns as opposed to Garden Villages;
  • Where Garden Communities have already begun to deliver, they have typically comprised extensions to existing settlements, namely; Bicester, Aylesbury and Didcot;
  • Lichfields finds that – based on a high level trajectory of delivery across the programme – of the 403,000 homes, just 35,000 are likely to be built by 2024 and only after that is the programme likely to be building at full tilt;
  • The peak period for housebuilding will likely be between 2030-2034 when 16,000 homes are projected to be built each year (circa 5% of the national ambition for 300,000). Many projects in the programme are likely to be building out until 2050;
  • Government efforts to improve the pace of build out would be needed to increase the contribution those projects make within the shorter time period;
  • The new Garden Communities will support circa1.3m additional jobs over their construction period to 2050, and generate a combined local economic value through its build out of £87 billion, with a further benefits in terms of taxes.
Did you like this? Share it: